Fresh cheeses, deli meats, honey, and baked goods straight from Amish country to Chouteau, Oklahoma.
Pull up to 101 S Chouteau Ave and you'll immediately understand why people drive an hour or more to get here. The parking lot tells the story: license plates from across northeastern Oklahoma, families loading up coolers, and first-timers standing in the doorway trying to take it all in. With a 4.8-star rating across more than 2,500 reviews, Amish Cheese House has earned a reputation that no amount of advertising could buy.
The shelves are stocked with the kind of things you simply cannot find at a grocery chain. Fresh Amish honey in mason jars, slow-cooked apple butter, hand-cut deli meats, and an ever-rotating selection of artisan cheeses sourced directly from Amish communities. Every item has a story, a maker, and a reason it tastes different from anything else you've tried.
The staff here actually know the products. Ask about the Samokin' BBQ sauce and you'll get a full explanation of why regulars refuse to buy any other brand. That kind of genuine enthusiasm, paired with one-of-a-kind inventory, is exactly what keeps customers coming back every season.
The deli counter alone is worth the trip. Fresh-cut meats and cheeses are sliced to order, and the selection rotates with what's freshest. Whether you're building a charcuterie board or stocking up for the week, the staff will help you choose and slice exactly what you need.
Beyond the deli, the store carries an impressive spread of Amish pantry staples: raw honey, fruit butters, jams, pickles, and baked goods that arrive with the kind of texture and flavor only achieved without shortcuts. The bakery selection includes breads, cookies, and seasonal specialties that disappear fast.
The gift and specialty section rounds out the experience. Unique sauces like Samokin' BBQ, handcrafted preserves, and locally sourced products make this the go-to stop for anyone looking for a truly memorable hostess gift, holiday basket, or personal treat that can't be replicated with a quick online order.
Take a look at our space and what we have to offer
Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers
We're at 101 S Chouteau Ave in Chouteau, Oklahoma 74337. Chouteau is in Mayes County in northeastern Oklahoma, roughly an hour from the Tulsa metro area. Many customers make it a dedicated day trip.
Our inventory includes fresh-cut deli meats and artisan cheeses, raw Amish honey, fruit butters, jams, pickles, baked goods, and specialty sauces including the fan-favorite Samokin' BBQ. We also carry unique gift items and Amish-crafted pantry staples that you won't find in conventional grocery stores.
For the most current information on online ordering or shipping availability, please visit our website at amishcheesehouse.com. Many of our products are perishable or limited in quantity, so visiting in person gives you the best selection.
Hours can vary by season. We recommend checking our website at amishcheesehouse.com or calling ahead before making a long drive, especially around holidays or during winter months when hours may be adjusted.
Absolutely. Customers regularly pick up Amish honey, apple butter, specialty BBQ sauces, and handcrafted preserves as gifts. The products are genuinely unique and feel personal in a way that a store-bought gift card never could.
The deli counter features meats and cheeses cut fresh to order. Bakery items are brought in regularly and sell out quickly, so earlier visits in the day tend to offer the best selection of breads, cookies, and seasonal baked goods.
Based on customer feedback, yes. Multiple long-term customers have noted that Samokin' BBQ sauce is exclusively available at Amish Cheese House and cannot be found elsewhere, which is why many regulars stock up on each visit.
Local places a short distance away, each with its own Doozer site. Tap any card to visit.
17 mi33604 Long Bay Rd, Wagoner, OK 74467, USA
19 mi1820 Summit Dr, Claremore, OK 74017, USA
24 mi10266 S 241st E Ave, Broken Arrow, OK 74014, USA
30 mi4421 S Mingo Rd, Tulsa, OK 74146, USA
34 mi5335 S Harvard Ave, Tulsa, OK 74135, USA
Other spots near here, whatever their type. Tap one to open its page.